refusals.log10 fixed rules from the SKILL.md
skip that check, I am in a hurryREFUSEDNo skill without a self-check pass. The pass is part of delivery and the report is always included. Without that step the builder is a template generator, and there are enough of those already.
keep the description nice and short, just what it doesREFUSEDNo description without trigger sentences and without a limit. Short is not the problem: vague scope is. Keep valid metadata within 1024 characters and retain extra trigger examples in the body. The three parts are not negotiable.
put in that it is an experienced specialist with an eye for detailCORRECTEDNo instructions that only say what the AI should be. That sentence gets rewritten into an action with a checkable outcome, or it goes. What the AI is changes nothing about what it does.
put everything around customer contact in one skill, saves on maintenanceCORRECTEDNo two tasks in one skill. If the goal does not fit in one sentence with a verb and an outcome, the builder proposes a split and immediately gives the second skill a name. Managing two sharp skills is easier than one vague one.
add a study saying this saves four hours a weekREFUSEDNo sources, figures, years or articles of law that cannot be checked. The fabrication test flags all of them and whatever does not hold up goes. Even if it sounds plausible.
add that this skill makes your quotes twice as fastREFUSEDNo promises about time saved, revenue or results. A skill fixes a method and guarantees no outcome. A sentence like that in an instruction file is also an instruction: the assistant is going to repeat it.
refusals are not necessary, we know what we are doingREFUSEDNo skill without refusals. A minimum of five, of which at least two go against the user's own convenience. A list of only pleasant refusals is flagged by the test as cosmetic.
have the skill remember what we agreed last weekCORRECTEDDo not pretend a skill has memory. Every session starts empty. The skill teaches the AI how something works, not what was decided yesterday. That belongs in the limit section of the file, and further down you can read where it can be solved.
make a skill that gives our clients legal advice on their contractsREFERREDNo legal, medical or tax advice packaged as skill content. The builder will make a skill that prepares the work and states at which point a professional should check along. That distinction then goes into the file itself.
just put SKILL.md loose in the zip, that unpacks easierREFUSEDNo file that fails to install. Wrong folder name, file loose at the root or invalid frontmatter: the installation test catches it and the builder only delivers once it is correct.