The write-up is a retelling. Then Pete said this, after which Karen remarked that, and a discussion followed. Chronology feels thorough, but the reader is not after a film, they are after the outcome. That is why every write-up from this skill opens with a summary of five lines at most: what has been decided, what needs to happen, what is still open. Whoever reads only those five lines knows enough. That is Minto's Pyramid Principle, applied to meetings: conclusion first.
Proposals quietly turn into decisions. The most dangerous sentence in a meeting is "we were all agreed on that, weren't we". A decision that was never made then appears in the minutes, and three weeks later someone feels blindsided. Hence the explicitness test: a decision only goes into the list of decisions if it was explicitly made in the source. Someone proposes it and there is agreement, or the chair confirms it. Everything short of that is an open item, with the reason next to it.
Action points without an owner and without a moment. "I will take a look" is the kiss of death for any action point. Getting Things Done by David Allen has been saying it since 2001: an action without an owner is a wish, an action without a next step stays put. That is why the skill forces an owner and a deadline for every action point, and where the source does not contain those, it does not guess but writes [FILL IN], with a note on which fragment was unclear.
Quote and interpretation run into each other. There is a real difference between "Sanne said the newsletter costs more than it brings in" and "the newsletter costs more than it brings in". The first sentence is a record, the second is a conclusion nobody has drawn. The two stay strictly separate: literal statements sit between quotation marks with a name attached, and anything the skill infers or summarises is marked as interpretation.
The write-up passes judgement. "Heated discussion", "not a very constructive attitude", "well prepared": those are judgements, not facts. They belong in a performance review, not in minutes the whole team reads. What was said and decided goes in, and the interpretation stays with the people themselves.
In diff form, with lines from the skill's own example: what goes out and what comes back in its place.
--- retelling.txt
+++ minutes.md # this is how the skill rewrites it, lines based on the example
A lively discussion about the newsletter followed.
O1. Stopping the newsletter: proposal from Sanne, deferred by Joris to the next meeting. No decision.
Tim indicated he would look into this shortly.
A1. Supply the figures · owner: Tim · deadline: [FILL IN] ("I will take a look" names no time)
The meeting agreed that the quote has priority.
D1. The quote for Bergman goes out this week (proposed by Sanne, no objection).