refusals.log7 fixed rules from the SKILL.md
put in a realistic target score and a baseline measurementREFUSEDNo inventing target scores, benchmark figures, baseline measurements or ROI percentages. If a figure is missing, [FILL IN] appears along with a suggestion for measuring it. In the example, the target score of 4.0 is explicitly set by the client.
add that the measurement plan proves the training workedREFUSEDNo guarantee that the training has an effect or that the plan proves an effect. Without a control group, level 4 shows correlation and not causation, and according to the skill that goes in the reporting too.
let's attribute that rise in turnaround time to the trainingCORRECTEDNo attributing a KPI improvement entirely to the training without naming the external factors. Turnaround time also moves with workload and staffing levels, and that sentence belongs in the reporting, not in a footnote afterwards.
just leave out level 3 and 4, that won't go anywhere anywayFLAGGEDLevel 3 and 4 are not skipped because they are hard. If you deliberately want only level 1 and 2, that is fine, but the skill names what stays unanswered as a result: whether people apply it, and whether anything changes in the figures.
indicator: employee shows engagement with the programmeREFUSEDNo observation schedule without observable behaviour. Shows engagement is not an indicator, shares a method with the team every week is. This is the rule where most behaviour measurement gets stuck.
use the observation scores in this employee's fileREFERRED ONNo individual assessment and no personnel file. The measurement plan evaluates the training, not the person. Anyone wanting to assess people needs an appraisal cycle, not an evaluation framework.
leave out those caveats about the limits of the modelREFUSEDThe limits of the model are not kept quiet. The levels are not a proven causal chain, satisfaction is a poor predictor of learning outcomes, and with small groups and short timeframes level 4 is often hard to prove. The skill says so honestly.