Persuading with text: AIDA, StoryBrand, SCQA and Cialdini side by side
Writing advice often focuses on wording, while structure, purpose, audience and the actual offer also matter. The models below provide different ways to organise and review persuasive text. They are practical lenses, not proof that one sequence causes every reader to act or that most failures have the same cause.
This article compares four central approaches and two related ones: AIDA, StoryBrand, SCQA, Cialdini, Made to Stick and the Pyramid Principle. Complete fictional examples show how wording and organisation can differ; they are not measured conversion results or reusable client claims. The free selector provides instructions for choosing a model and reviewing a draft, with human verification still required.
- Unzip it into
~/.claude/skills/(or.claude/skills/in your project). - The description explains when the skill is intended to apply. Automatic discovery and model compliance are not guaranteed for every request.
- Start Claude Code with claude, then enter
/writing-model-selectorinside the session.
- Go to Customize and then Skills.
- Upload the zip there as a skill.
- Or paste the contents of SKILL.md into the project instructions of a Project.
- Open
AGENTS.mdin your repo. - Paste the contents of SKILL.md into it, or place SKILL.md alongside it as a separate file and reference it from
AGENTS.md. - Codex reads that along with every session.
Four central models, two related approaches
reg. O.001A company-history advert, a proposal with a buried conclusion or a homepage dominated by the sender may have structural weaknesses. Those are hypotheses to investigate, not proof that model choice causes most SME copy failures. Pronoun counts are a prompt for judgement, not a quality score. Start with the task and evidence, then use the matrix as a provisional route to a suitable model.
Four familiar steps for reviewing copy
reg. O.002AIDA names Attention, Interest, Desire and Action. It is traditionally associated with E. St. Elmo Lewis and 1898, but Akinori Iwamoto’s original archival research challenges that origin account. The often-repeated attribution of the acronym to C.P. Russell in 1921 was not checked here against the original Printers’ Ink article. These names and dates are retained as qualified attributions, not a verified sole-inventor story or proof of universal use.
The key insight isn't the order but the diagnosis: the stages can suggest questions about a draft. Text alone does not establish actual drop-off or identify a single cause; confirm hypotheses with suitable evidence. How to apply this to adverts is also covered in the guide to Google Ads ad copy NL; the AIDA copywriter skill applies the model automatically.
The customer is the hero, you are the guide
reg. O.003Donald Miller’s 2017 Building a StoryBrand presents the seven-element SB7 framework. It casts the customer as a character with a problem and the business as a guide offering a plan and call to action, with failure and success in view. That is a possible organising perspective, not proof that most websites make the same mistake or that the business has already solved every customer’s problem.
It sounds like marketing talk but it is an editorial perspective, not a grammar rule requiring the reader to be the subject of every sentence. Count it on your own homepage; if it says we more often than you, inspect the focus rather than mechanically replacing pronouns. The StoryBrand writer skill builds the complete framework for your brand.
The opening that makes a decision question clear
reg. O.004SCQA comes from Barbara Minto, associated with McKinsey and structured business writing. This does not establish that openings cause most document failures. Her solution: start with the Situation the reader already knows and agrees with, then introduce the Complication that disturbs that picture, make explicit the Question that follows from it, and give the Answer straight away. No warm-up rounds, no methodology chapter up front. A concise opening can state context and answer, but four sentences do not guarantee attention or comprehension. For proposal drafting this offers a possible approach: the SCQA communication coach skill rebuilds every opening to this pattern, and the quote writer skill does the same for the whole proposal.
Why people say yes, in seven principles
reg. O.005Robert Cialdini isn't a copywriter but a behavioural scientist. His 1984 book Influence described six principles relevant to influence, not deterministic laws for every response, and the expanded 2021 edition added unity, also discussed in Pre-Suasion in 2016: shared identity, not simply liking. Cialdini isn't a structural model: you don't build a text with it. It's the layer you place over an existing structure once the text works but the reader is still hesitating. The art is in dosing it and, more importantly, staying honest: truth and relevant context are ethical requirements, not proof that falsehood can never persuade or that truth guarantees success. The Cialdini persuasion skill checks which principles are honestly available in your text and works them in without overdoing it.
Made to Stick: reviewing whether a message is memorable
Persuasion and later recall are different outcomes. Chip and Dan Heath’s 2007 Made to Stick offers the SUCCESs framework: Simple, Unexpected, Concrete, Credible, Emotional, Stories. These six lenses can guide planning or review, but an editor’s assessment is not a measured memory or conversion result. Test what readers actually understand and remember when that evidence is needed.
A central idea in the book: the curse of knowledge
Expertise can make it harder to notice what a beginner does not yet know. That is a reason to test explanations with the intended reader, not proof that experts can never imagine another perspective. Concrete examples, useful surprise and stories may help; a story can still be abstract or unclear. Keep the underlying facts and ask what the reader actually understood.
Use the six lenses while planning or reviewing, not as six mandatory sections
Hold your core message up against the six building blocks and see where it fails. Can a customer repeat what you do after reading it once? Does it contain one concrete image, or only qualities? Is the evidence checkable? Review the draft, then test recall with actual readers if needed; no automatic one-half reduction or measured recall result follows from the checklist. The Made to Stick coach skill runs exactly that test: it checks your message against the six building blocks and rewrites what doesn't stick.
Pyramid Principle: the document behind the SCQA opening
Barbara Minto’s Pyramid Principle puts a conclusion above its supporting reasoning and relevant detail. Her McKinsey interview supports the 1985 book date, followed by a Pearson publication in 1987. This is not evidence that almost every consultancy uses it or that almost every reader stops after one paragraph. Consider an SCQA opening where it helps explain the question before arranging the argument.
MECE helps assess parallel categories within a defined scope
MECE means mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive. Use it when categories are intended to divide a defined subject: check overlaps and gaps against that scope. Not every story or deductive argument is such a partition. Three distinct proposal reasons can be useful, but neither three nor five is a universal quota, and removing repetition must not remove necessary evidence.
For anyone writing a lot of business documents, it can provide a reusable organising method, but its return and suitability have not been measured against alternatives here. The Pyramid Principle writer skill rebuilds an existing document into a pyramid: conclusion first, arguments MECE, details at the bottom. Combine it with the SCQA opening from section 04 as one possible organising approach, not a complete or universally mandated McKinsey method. If that pyramid needs to become a presentation rather than a document, the Pitch Deck Builder NL does the same work across eight slides: one core sentence per slide, the reasoning underneath it, and the counter-question your audience is going to ask.
Combining them without it turning into a patchwork
There is no universally best model or required stack of all six. Choose for the channel, reader, desired action and available evidence. StoryBrand may help perspective, AIDA a short sequence, and SCQA plus a pyramid a business explanation. Consider zero to two honestly supported Cialdini principles as an optional layer, then use Made to Stick where recall matters. These are choices to justify and test, not a conversion recipe.
What doesn't work is trying to cram everything into one paragraph at once
An opening sentence that needs to grab attention, introduce a hero, sketch a situation and deliver social proof may become overloaded; judge the actual sentence rather than treating overlap as inherently ineffective. Pick one load-bearing model per text and let the others ride along as a checklist. If you're unsure which model should carry the weight, the choice matrix in section 01 is the shortest route, and the persuasion analyst skill is the most thorough: it analyses an existing text across every layer at once and names where the weakest one sits.
One more warning that's missing from no writing book yet still gets ignored on plenty of websites: persuading is arranging what's true, not inventing what sounds good. Invented reviews, false scarcity and borrowed authority can mislead and harm readers; this does not establish a universal one-use effect or permanent outcome. Every example sentence in this article is therefore deliberately a fictional illustration of the mechanism, not a client case. The same rule applies to your own text: truthful claims still need relevant context, material qualifications and respect for the reader’s choice. Anyone who wants to work on their message structurally rather than text by text should look at strategy: that's where this kind of work belongs, as part of an ongoing plan.
From model to practice: let AI do the heavy lifting
A skill supplies structured instructions for an AI assistant, not a guarantee of flawless application. The selector asks for diagnosis, model choice and a labelled draft; inspect whether the actual output follows it and preserves the facts. With no original text, it must say No original text supplied rather than invent a before version. This review has not tested a model’s runtime compliance or measured a conversion improvement.
The writing-model picker for this article is the first step: it guides a justified choice from six, a labelled draft and an evidence check; inspect the actual output
Want to go deeper afterwards? There's a specialist ready for each model: AIDA, StoryBrand, SCQA, Cialdini, Made to Stick and Pyramid Principle. If you're writing mainly for findability, the SEO copywriter skill NL combines these persuasion principles with search intent and structure, and creating content for AI search engines discusses AI-search discovery without guaranteeing that this text is cited.
All the downloads together are in the skills overview, well over a hundred of them, all free and with no account needed
How we use AI more broadly in marketing work is covered in the engine room, and anyone who'd rather first read how their site is doing right now can have the free SEO scan take a look: search access and persuasive usefulness are different questions; an unindexed page can still have direct readers.
Frequently asked questions
Which writing model should I choose for a landing page?
Use the visitor’s task and verified context, not traffic source alone. A specific search advert may suggest an immediate need, but does not prove familiarity; brand search is not inherently a cold audience. AIDA can help a short action-focused sequence, while StoryBrand may help perspective. Explain the choice, preserve evidence and test the resulting page rather than guarantee a response.
What's the difference between AIDA and StoryBrand?
AIDA offers Attention, Interest, Desire and Action as a writing and review sequence; it does not establish that every reader moves through four observable stages. StoryBrand uses the customer/guide perspective and seven story elements. They can overlap, but neither identifies an actual cause of drop-off from text alone. Choose a useful organising model and explain why it suits the task.
Can I combine several writing models?
You can combine models when each has a clear purpose, but more models do not automatically make better copy. Choose an organising structure, then optionally review evidence with zero to two supported Cialdini principles and assess recall with Made to Stick. Keep unknowns visible and avoid forcing every framework into every paragraph. The two-principle ceiling is this selector’s editorial convention.
Do these models also work for SEO copy?
These models can help organise useful, reader-focused copy, but are not separate ranking requirements or proof of longer visits. Answer the relevant need with accurate information and a suitable action. An answer-first opening may resemble a pyramid; an AIDA sequence still requires testing. No SEO or AI-citation outcome follows automatically from applying a writing model.
Aren't Cialdini's principles just manipulation?
Truthful, relevant persuasion must preserve the reader’s ability to choose. Real evidence, accurate terms and genuine availability are essential; a true statement can still mislead through context or omitted qualifications. Do not invent reviews, scarcity, credentials or shared identity. A reset countdown falsely presented as a real deadline is misleading. No principle is blanket permission for pressure or a legal-compliance guarantee.
Can AI apply these writing models to my own text?
The free downloads provide working instructions for Claude or Codex, including diagnosis, a justified choice and a labelled draft. They cannot guarantee that a model follows those instructions or that the text performs better. Verify facts and test relevant outcomes. No original text means a new draft, not a fabricated before example. Downloading needs no account; using the AI product may have its own access requirements.
Start with the model, not the sentence
Begin with the reader’s task, the desired action and substantiated facts. The matrix can help select a structure and the fictional comparisons illustrate possible wording changes; they do not prove improved persuasion. Use the skills as working instructions, inspect the draft and test a meaningful outcome with a denominator and comparison where feasible.
Want to know whether your text gets found at all before making it more persuasive? Start with the free scan. More articles like this one are in the knowledge base, what this kind of work costs is on the pricing page NL, and how text fits into the bigger picture of findability is covered under improving your SEO. Would rather think out loud about your own text? Then let's do that in a call, or reach us via the contact page.